Sunday, July 31, 2011

Liar, liar, pants on fire.

The Reader's Digest claims that people lie up to two or three times every ten minutes. That sounds a little pathological to me. I don't usually even talk that much.

The magazine also stated that society would collapse if we didn't because we most often lie to protect the feelings of others.

I'm not convinced either of those statements are true. Particularly the latter.

I believe children learn very early on that lying is a handy little tool to keep oneself out of trouble. When mom or dad asks whether or not their child ( who didn't brush his teeth) has brushed their teeth, I don't think the child says yes to protect the parent from feeling bad about their parenting skills.

But it got me thinking. Because I do think that everyone does lie. And I also think some lies are more detrimental than others even though if we probe deeply and are honest with ourselves, even the lies that we tell for the sake of others often have some self serving element to them.

Consider this, a coworker asks if you like her new outfit. You don't, but you say you do. Why? To protect her feelings of course, but also, because we are being honest here, we want her to like us. We want her to think we are nice.

I don't want to over think this too much because it's hard to ever find a truly pure motive. I certainly wouldn't tell someone I thought they were wearing a silly outfit. I wouldn't say anything at all......unless I was asked. In that case I would find something nice to say if at all possible. You know, pretty color, or fabric, or it brings out your eyes. But if I couldn't think of anything, yes, I would probably have to resort to the lie. To spare them as well as myself.

Is that wrong? If it is, is it wrong enough to warrant all that much attention? Because I've noticed that we tend to over emphasize lesser evils while ignoring issues that seem to be far more damaging. Sweating the small stuff is actually easier than changing the big stuff.

Anyway, all this got me thinking about lying in general. I hate being lied to. It's the hardest thing for me to deal with. It makes me angry and I have to work hard to forgive it and trust then becomes very difficult.

I would rather hear the hard truth than be lied to. Or so I think. ( I have a son who insists women almost never want to hear the truth.) I guess it depends on the subject. The are plenty of things I would just rather not know, period.

But what is it that makes lying so prevalent. Or necessary?

I want to exclude lies that are told for the sake of mercy. We all know about the sheltering of Jews from the Nazis. I wish we had another name for that kind of a lie. It needs its own category that completely removes the negative connotation.

I have been accused of lying about my past situation. I was accused of hypocrisy. Of pretending to believe things I did not.

That isn't true. But that doesn't mean my accusers are lying. They just don't understand what happened. Well,one accuser is lying. But he did understand what happened and is simply trying to protect himself.

I have thought so much about what I used to believe, what I believe now, and what I don't know enough about to believe or disbelieve.

Much has changed. Does that make me a liar? I don't think so. I have just changed. My thinking has changed. My situation has changed.

I taught a bible study for 12 years. I believed what I taught. I studied hard to present the truth of what I had learned.

All the while I was caught in a terrible situation with the pastor of that church which I have written about previously.

From the beginning, I went over all my notes with this man and relied heavily on his opinion. I didn't trust my own. I believed what he said. For some reason I was able to trust his knowledge of the bible and his ability to discern even though I knew that what he was doing to me was sinful in anyone's book. Of course in the beginning I was still blaming myself.

As the years went by, I began to trust myself a little more and when I had a difference of opinion I would entertain it a little bit. Usually he would convince me otherwise or I would just defer to his views for the sake of "unity". Or fear of upsetting him. Most often I simply figured I must be wrong because he couldn't be. He had to be right. It was his job, his calling, and more sadly, my need to keep him right so my world wouldn't come apart.

I was so fearful. Afraid of everything. All my life. It seems to me that fearful people need more absolutes. Absolutes are a floor to stand on when we feel as though we're falling. Something to be sure of when you're not sure of anything.

I do believe in absolutes. I just don't believe we know them all or completely, and very often we are wrong about the ones of which we are so convinced. Even the bible says that now we see in a mirror dimly.

I had far more fear in my life three years ago. And more absolutes. I believed them with all my heart. So much so that I taught them to others.

While I still think some of those things are true, many of them turned out to be false. No longer black and white, as I had thought, but every shade of gray and and a wide spectrum of colors in between.

So my question is,

What, really, is a lie?

Is a lie in and of itself a bad thing, or can it be a good thing? Is it based on perspective? Is it based on what we know to be true? Or false? And very importantly, at the time.

How often do we accuse people of lying because we don't understand, or simply don't believe them. If this is the case, do we make them liars, or do we make ourselves liars?

We all have a filter through which we receive information. We forget that sometimes. People may comment on something they feel is completely benign, but because our experience has clogged our filter to alter our view in a different way we are hurt or angry.

One of the mistakes may be that we forget they have a filter as well. We think they see things as we do and should know better. Another thing I think we do is to not respond with compassion when someone else mistakes our meaning or disagrees with it.

We don't want to acknowledge that they, like we, believe what they perceive at the time.

It's easier to simply make them wrong. They may be wrong, so might we, but wrong doesn't necessarily connote evil. Its just so much easier to think someone a liar if we don't want to hear what they have to say. If we view them as a liar, we don't need to listen. We can blow them off, so to speak.

And isn't it funny that when there is disagreement, each regards the other as the offending party. For example, if someone tells you something that turns out to be wrong, they a. Lied. b. Meant to hurt. c. Don't care. or d. Anything negative that comes to mind.

But if we tell someone else something untrue, a. We didn't mean it. b. We meant no harm. c. We care very much, (they should know that, of course.) or d. Any positive spin we can apply.

Shouldn't we try to at least give others the same understanding we give ourselves? And the same forgiveness as well?

I know it's easier said than done. But for me, at least, keeping it in mind helps a great deal.

So when I think I'm being lied to I must step back and take a breath. Unclog my filter. Realize I'm dealing with a fellow human being.

This doesn't mean I drop my guard. That's not practical or even safe. Some of us need to trust our intuition more than we do, some less. Boundaries are good. Both ways.

It's the snap judgement, the condemnation, the certainty that we seem to have of another's thoughts that is the issue here.

I think that may be the ultimate lie. To believe we are always right about other people. Even when there is no possible way to know.

So to those who have settled their minds on what I did or didn't do. What I think or don't think. What I believe or don't believe.

Y'know......you could ask me.

And if you don't...... well that's up to you. What someone thinks of any of us, changes none of us.

Though what another says affects our circumstances and relationships, still, what can we do but go on, live our lives the best we know how?

Am I lying myself?

Would I know it if I were?

I truly don't believe we can knowingly lie to ourselves. That we would know. We can only be mistaken. Its easy to convince ourselves of things that aren't true.

But even for those who lie to others so often that they begin to believe their own lies, doesn't that belief make it true for them, even though they may be tragically wrong?

My quest is to be as honest with myself as I can bear right now. And as honest with others as I possibly can. Tomorrow I may be able to bear a little bit more.

It's one more painful process. But one worth the effort and the tears.

And you know what else?

It's not so hard to admit to having been wrong. I've had a lot of practice.

But I'd rather be sorry than dishonest.



































No comments:

Post a Comment